Dr Andy Higgins MD

Special Care is Our Practice.

  • Home
  • About
    • Certifications
    • Education
    • Gratitudes
    • Local Partners
    • Perspectives
    • Philosophy
    • Positions
  • Our Services
    • Breast Care
    • General Surgery
      • Hernia Symptoms and Repair – General Surgeon
  • Resources
    • Articles – Surgery and Cancer
      • Appendicitis FAQ Sheet
      • Breast Cancer Screening Mammogram Guidelines
      • Hernia Symptoms and Repair – General Surgeon
      • The History of General Surgery – A Brief Overview
      • Tips for Facing Breast Cancer
    • Breast Surgery
    • General Surgery Resources
    • Insurance Info
    • Patient Intake Documents
    • Pre-Op Instructions
    • Post-Op Instructions
    • Self Exam
    • Website Resources
  • Blog
    • Breast Cancer Research Articles
    • Breast Cancer News and Stories
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Articles - Surgery and Cancer / Genetic Roulette: Why Skipping Testing Could Cost You—and Your Family

Genetic Roulette: Why Skipping Testing Could Cost You—and Your Family

The moment a breast-cancer diagnosis—or even a suspicious mammogram—lands in your life, the question “Is it in my genes?” jumps to the front of the line. Roughly 5-10 percent of breast cancers are tied to inherited mutations, yet knowing your personal risk can change everything: surgical choices, family planning, even peace of mind. This guide breaks down today’s genetic-testing landscape in plain English so you can decide, with your surgeon and genetic counselor, whether a simple blood draw or cheek swab could give you leverage over uncertainty.

breast cancer genetic testing illustration

Genetics vs. Family History—A Quick Reality Check

Having two aunts with breast cancer at age 60 isn’t the same as carrying a high-risk mutation yourself.

  • Most breast cancers are sporadic—they happen even when no one else in the family has been affected.
  • Hereditary cancers start with a DNA typo present from birth. These mutations can march down a family tree if left undetected.
  • Red flags that suggest a hereditary component:
    • Multiple relatives diagnosed under age 50
    • Bilateral (both-breast) cancer in one person
    • Any male breast cancer
    • Relatives with ovarian, pancreatic, or metastatic prostate cancer

Who Should Consider Testing?

Guidelines evolve every year, but most experts (NCCN, USPSTF, American Society of Breast Surgeons) agree on three high-priority groups:

  • Personal history triggers
    • Breast cancer diagnosed before age 50
    • Triple-negative breast cancer before age 60
    • Male breast cancer at any age
    • Second, new breast cancer or bilateral disease
  • Family history triggers
    • First- or second-degree relative with breast, ovarian, pancreatic, or high-grade prostate cancer—especially under age 50
    • Multiple cancers on the same side of the family
  • Ancestry factors
    • Ashkenazi Jewish heritage (founder mutations are more common)
    • Certain Latin American, African, or French-Canadian backgrounds with documented founder mutations

Testing is a shared decision: you, your surgeon, and a certified genetic counselor weigh medical benefit, emotional readiness, and insurance coverage before ordering the panel.

What Gets Tested—Beyond BRCA

Early on we focused almost exclusively on BRCA1 and BRCA2. Today, multigene “panel” tests read dozens of cancer-related genes at once for about the same cost as the old two-gene test. The most common high- and moderate-risk genes include:

  • BRCA1/BRCA2 – classic heavy-hitters; up to 65-72 percent lifetime breast-cancer risk
  • PALB2 – partners with BRCA2; similar risk profile
  • CHEK2 & ATM – moderate risk; influence screening frequency rather than preventative surgery for many
  • TP53 – linked to Li-Fraumeni syndrome; multiple early cancers
  • CDH1, PTEN, STK11 – rarer but significantly raise lobular breast-cancer risk

Panels are run on a tube of blood or a cheek swab. Turnaround averages two to three weeks, and results arrive in a written report your team will walk through line by line.

Reading the Report Without a Decoder Ring

Genetic reports sort findings into four buckets:

  • Positive (Pathogenic/Likely Pathogenic) – a typo proven to raise cancer risk
  • Negative – no dangerous variants detected, but standard population risk still applies
  • VUS (Variant of Uncertain Significance) – “grey zone” changes that science hasn’t classified yet; treated as negative until reclassified
  • Benign/Likely Benign – harmless spelling differences in the DNA code

Important truths:

  • A positive result signals higher risk; it does not guarantee cancer.
  • A negative result cuts out one suspect but doesn’t eliminate all risk. Keep up with routine screening.
  • A VUS should never guide big surgical decisions. Your care team watches scientific databases for re-classification and will update you.
  • You never have to interpret a report alone—schedule a post-test counseling visit before you leave the building.

How Results Shape Surgical Choices

When a high-risk mutation is confirmed, the conversation often shifts: Is breast-conserving surgery still right for me, or does prophylactic mastectomy make more sense?

  • Risk-reducing mastectomy can drop future breast-cancer risk by 90 percent or more. Some patients pair it with immediate reconstruction (implant or DIEP-flap) to wake up with a breast mound in place.
  • Breast-conserving surgery (lumpectomy) plus radiation remains reasonable for many, especially with moderate-risk genes. Enhanced screening—annual MRI plus mammogram—tags along.
  • Ovarian risk rides shotgun with BRCA1/2 and several other genes; prophylactic salpingo-oophorectomy (removal of tubes and ovaries) between ages 35-45 is often advised.
    All decisions are personal. Your life plans, body image, and tolerance for risk matter as much as the raw numbers on a chart.

The Ripple Effect—Why Your Family Needs to Know

One positive test isn’t just your information; it’s a heads-up to siblings, children, even cousins who share your DNA. That process—cascade testing—can save lives decades before cancer has a chance to knock.

  • Discuss results in a quiet setting; offer written resources or invite relatives to join a counseling session.
  • Insurance usually covers testing for blood relatives once a pathogenic mutation is documented.
  • Children under 18 generally wait; adult offspring may test as soon as they feel ready.

Emotional and Spiritual Well-Being

News about “faulty genes” can trigger guilt (“Did I pass this on?”), fear, or déjà vu for families who have already lost loved ones. You are not alone.

  • Lean on support groups—local or virtual—where shared stories strip shame from statistics.
  • Integrate faith practices if that grounds you. Many patients find strength in seeing knowledge as stewardship: “I can act wisely because I see the road ahead.”
  • Professional counseling is appropriate at any stage—pre-test, post-result, during surgical decision-making, or years into survivorship.

Costs, Coverage, and Logistics

Good news: genetic testing is far cheaper than a decade ago, and most U.S. insurers cover guideline-driven tests with minimal out-of-pocket costs.

  • Typical cash price ranges $250-$400 if uninsured; labs often cap patient responsibility.
  • Always verify that your lab is in-network before the blood draw.
  • Financial-assistance programs exist—your navigator or counselor can apply on your behalf.

Five Common Myths—Debunked

  • “A negative test means I’m safe forever.” You still need routine mammography because most breast cancers are not hereditary.
  • “A positive test guarantees I’ll get cancer.” It signals risk, not destiny; surveillance and preventive options slash odds dramatically.
  • “Insurers or employers will use my genetic info against me.” U.S. law (GINA) bars health-insurance and employment discrimination.
  • “Testing is only valuable for young women.” Knowledge shapes screening and ovarian risk reduction at any age.
  • “Life insurance will be denied.” Many policies don’t ask for genetic information; those that do focus on active medical history, not test results alone.

Take-Home Checklist

  • Talk with your breast-surgery team or primary oncologist about your eligibility.
  • Collect a three-generation family tree—including ages at diagnosis—to bring to your counseling visit.
  • Obtain pre-authorization from your insurer or explore financial aid if needed.
  • Decide ahead of time whom you’ll share results with and how.
  • Schedule any recommended MRIs, ultrasounds, or follow-up consults before you leave the clinic.

Genetic testing is a flashlight, not a fortune-teller. When you shine it on your DNA, you don’t just reveal risk—you light up a pathway to smarter choices, earlier detection, and, if appropriate, preventive action that can outmaneuver cancer before it starts. If you’re ready to explore whether testing makes sense for you, call us at (541) 749-7000 to walk through your questions. Your genes may start the story, but together we can help you write the next chapters on your terms.

Knowledge is prudence. Let’s use it.

Filed Under: Articles - Surgery and Cancer, Breast Cancer

Andrew P. Higgins
MD FACS
Board Certified General Surgeon

Bend breast care doctor
Office hours
8am-5pm, M-F
2450 NE Mary Rose Pl, Suite 205
Bend, OR 97701
office: (541) 749-7000
fax: (541) 749-7005

Breast Cancer Awareness, Dr. Higgins, Bend
click here for info

Copyright © 2025 · Beautiful Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in